Rendered at 07:05:10 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
zabil 8 minutes ago [-]
Not a big fan of Arc because it felt sluggish. Using ZigZag now, really good job. I think the UX from first-time usage is spot on and well thought out. Quite pleasant to use and it feels snappy.
I used firefox for a while but switched back because some sites didn't or rather some plugins caused issues with sites. The only thing I miss from firefox is how it managed containers and pinning websites to containers. Do recommend looking at that feature.
computerfriend 22 hours ago [-]
> I don’t want to switch back to boring tabs along the top.
Also on Firefox, I'm a big proponent of Sidebery (https://addons.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/addon/sidebery/), which gives you tab spaces like in Arc, vertical tabs, and (most importantly for me) a tree-like layout where tabs can be children of other tabs. Like tab groups, but with more nesting and freedom! I've tried Zen in the past, but I find I can't really go back to not having the tree-style organisation.
pindab0ter 17 hours ago [-]
I'm a big fan of how Arc and Zen handle pinned tabs; you can just unload them instead of actually closing them with my favourite shortcut. That was honestly the biggest reason to not go back to plain Firefox despite their great implementation of vertical tabs.
philistine 16 hours ago [-]
Safari in 27.3's beta has vertical tabs. I'm sure the depth of the feature-set is lacking, but as a neophyte to vertical tabs, I like it a lot.
Enroll in the beta, or wait a couple of weeks for the release.
DiabloD3 22 hours ago [-]
I came here to also say this. I've been using vertical tabs under Firefox for like 2 years now.
Chrome (and Chromium-based) browsers are basically DOA now, and no reason to daily driver them if they can't implement a simple feature like this.
raulparada 22 hours ago [-]
Chrome has vertical tabs since April
DiabloD3 22 hours ago [-]
I'm sorry, but that's a bit of a too little too late. Google chose Chrome's path, and copying Firefox isn't going to help them turn that ship around.
Like, I'm surprised anyone takes Chrome seriously at all after Google was told to not misuse their monopoly position as the world's largest ad company and remove the ability for the world's most popular ad blocker and security extension to work, and then did it anyways.
... and then promptly bullied all Chromium-based browsers to merge the Manifest V2 removal patches.
cyberrock 21 hours ago [-]
Copying Firefox? Firefox's implementation is inferior to extensions that have been in AMO for 15 years. Meanwhile Arc implemented tree tabs for the 3 years it exists.
Talking about Manifest v3 is hypocticial when Firefox basically did the same thing to sidebar extensions. Tree Style Tabs had to fight for its extension APIs when they switched to Web Extensions (or it might have been Quantum?). Not to mention that they made userChrome disabled by default so TST/Sideberry users like me have to do a bunch of shenanigans in about:config that they might randomly feel like removing one day.
As a hardcore Arc user, my take away is I'm not trusting anything that has significant human effort and funding behind it. I don't have the time - nor interest - to spare to move browsers constantly so I can only choose to invest in something with structure behind it.
pmkary 2 hours ago [-]
Thank you for the link! I was so happy to zee Zigzag (because I didn't like Zen and some other clones I saw) and then I went and am trying to test all of this browsers.
Something worth mentioning is that till this far, I samehow think Zigzag is suprisingly the best of all of them in terms of stability, coherence of the design, and sheer performance. It is really snappy, it doesn't have the overkill designs of the Arc (like the beautiful 3D opening of a folder for example) but it is more coherent than almost all the other versions I'm seening. But I hope I can find one even closer to Arc. Thanks again.
usrme 20 hours ago [-]
Also a hardcore user of Arc here. What are your current options with regards to Arc being sunset? I've tried a bunch and tried to emulate what I currently have with Arc, which just works, but none of them are exactly there. If Zen could have proper profile support, then that might push me over to their side...
ZigaoWang 18 hours ago [-]
If profiles are what ur missing, give Zigzag a try! Each space can have its own profile with seperate cookies and logins. You can also share cookies or logins if u still insist. All in one window like Arc. Arc imports well to Zigzag, you can bring in your spaces, pinned tabs and favorites over with a few clicks
usrme 17 hours ago [-]
Yeah, I saw that your clone and many others support it, but like the parent, I'm wary about moving over to a browser that is just the hobby project of a solo developer.
While great things can come from a solo developer, in this day and age it's not the mark of a well-engineered product it once was, in my eyes at least. I'm really hoping that a community springs up around one strong contender and it matures into something that can be trusted over many years to come.
NetOpWibby 12 hours ago [-]
Helium is what I use now and the bus factor is at least two.
mysticaltech- 22 hours ago [-]
I feel so happy seeing that Dia is nowhere close to the top of the list
ma101an 3 days ago [-]
I used the browser for a while. I love it.
It's "really" snappy. I can actually feel it, after using chromium for a while. Idk if Safari feels faster, but I am accustomed to the UX of Arc, so the same UX, to me, feels lot faster in Zigzag. So it's definitely a plus.
Really I cannot overstate how fast/responsive it is. So smooth, no jank (I have 16GB M4 Air, when using Arc I can definitely see a small jank when opening & closing sidebar or resizing sidebar, swapping across spaces...) which I don't see at all in Zigzag
Also, I like how I can use chrome extensions here. Even though it's not 100% compatible, I can use ones that I have in my chromium browrser: ublock origin, unhook, video-speed-controller etc...
Some of the things I missed in safari are here, which I love: The reader mode & automatic dark mode support (removes need for me to use an extension for these "features")
overall idk if this is made with 100% AI or made by someone who actually have lot of knowledge and experience with building browsers,
eitherways, from end user perspective,
I love how its like Arc, but faster & uses safari engine (so its lightweight in MacOS)
ZigaoWang 2 days ago [-]
Thank you so much, this made my day! Funny enough, my comment on the whole project got killed, weird. Let me see if I can ask the moderator to un-kill it sometime. The smoothness is something I care a lot about, because Arc users have high bars. The sidebar, space switching and tab animations all run on Core Animation, so they stay smooth even with lots of tabs open. Glad the Chrome extensions work for you. Extension support isn't 100% yet, so if one you use breaks, please open an issue on GitHub and I'll look at it. On the AI question: yes, I use AI tools a lot when coding, but I decide what goes in and test everything myself, every day, since it's my main browser now. Thanks again for trying it!
someguyiguess 20 hours ago [-]
Why are you talking to yourself?
Personability 16 hours ago [-]
?
ZigaoWang 19 hours ago [-]
[dead]
lukestevens 21 hours ago [-]
> Hello HN! I am Zigao, a high school student from Shanghai. I am new to HN so hello to y’all!
Hello! Going by the comments, you're getting the classic HN welcome :D
Awesome start wth Zigzag. I feel like browsers are ripe for innovation beyond Arc too. E.g.:
- What does it mean to manage tabs & bookmarks in an agentic age?
- What would a start page look like if an agent can fetch anything from anywhere?
- What do projects and history look like when you can let Claude rip on visualizations and exploration to track tasks over time, not just by window or grouping?
Just some food for thought! :)
alsetmusic 6 hours ago [-]
> What do projects and history look like when you can let Claude rip on visualizations and exploration to track tasks over time, not just by window or grouping?
I remember an experimental browser that was released a bunch of years ago, I think it was by a university professor and their students. Its primary feature was a visual layout that showed history as sort of a storyboard of which pages led to each successive page. It was a neat concept. I was only aware of a single release and I don't remember the name, but I'd peg its ship date as around the age of Digg though I more likely saw it on Slashdot.
1. Anyone remember that? 2. Maybe we'll see something useful like that again. I hope so.
ZigaoWang 18 hours ago [-]
Haha, thanks for the welcome! Good questions!. For now im keeping AI out of the browser itself, since if not done well, its quite an useless AI slop. Dia is TBC's new product, but most people dont really want to use it, since there's no point in paying an extra 20 dollars per month when you have Claude or ChatGPT subscription. But Zigzag is AI-friendly! There's an optional MCP server (off by default) so your own agent can use the browser when you let it.
aiexplore369 5 hours ago [-]
What is your plan to keep up yourself in a highly AI driven space , with almost companies having there own chat based browsers now , I mean this is no doubt a very enthusiastic project , but what do you think your game is to sustain , kudos !
etcetcetcetceta 21 hours ago [-]
Ignore the haters, it's better than Arc, it's faster and renders better, you've got me at least until Ladybird 1.0.
rampatra 22 hours ago [-]
Thanks for such a detailed write up. Learned many things. For me, as the person developing extensions, the most impressive thing that you did is filling the gap and letting Chrome extensions be installed in a WebKit browser without the devs having to do anything. That’s cool.
I am saying this because I hate having to write those conditions everywhere in my extension code to support different browsers, it’s error prone, and time taking. Now we have AI to do it and test it but earlier it was all me.
ZigaoWang 18 hours ago [-]
Thanks! That was the part I cared most about chrome extension supports. And if your extension ever behaves differenty in Zigzag than in chromium browser. please open an issue on GitHub or email me and I will look into it!
Congrats on the launch of the project, it's definitely well thought for a solo-dev.
Someone mentioned the heavy usage of Claude, but for me the concern is another one. It's about the sustainability of the project and if this is just going to be discontinued like what happened to Arc.
As a user that needs to change his browser, I would understand what's going to be the future direction of this and if it can be economically viable for you to continue to work on the project. And just because it's open it doesn't mean that someone is going to take over
ZigaoWang 19 hours ago [-]
Thanks! Fair question, since there's tons of Arc alternatives out there and it's reasonable to assume that most of them will end up dead. Honest answer: Zigzag is my daily browser now, and I'm a solo developer. I can't really promise this is going on forever, I really do hope it can last really long, because I enjoy using it myself. Its fully open source (Apache 2.0) and there are already many contributors and issues and PRs on GitHub. Anyone can pick it up and continue. If i ever stop, it keeps working, since it runs on WebKit and not Chromium. If I ever do something to make it sustainable, I would definitely not sell data or add ads or stuff. WHO WANTS THAT? I genuinely enjoy using Zigzag, and I will continue working on it as long as I can. I enjoy developing Zigzag! (sorry for my long and rambling answer, bad at organizing thoughts)
atrokhymchuk 22 hours ago [-]
I just don't get why do we need so many chrome repacks?
sheept 22 hours ago [-]
I feel like a repackaging of Chrome has to at least be Chromium based, which this is not
rpastuszak 21 hours ago [-]
How’s this a Chrome repack?
ordinaryradical 19 hours ago [-]
Looking forward to trying this. I have been on Zen for a while and agree it feels a little off. But my biggest concern with Zen is the security dimensions of having to install so many plugins to reproduce Arc features.
It feels like I’m one compromised plug-in update away from getting rolled…
ZigaoWang 18 hours ago [-]
[dead]
blntechie 22 hours ago [-]
Well done, I will try if and when there is a build for Linux which I doubt considering the WebKit base.
fouc 21 hours ago [-]
Epiphany (GNOME Web) is webkit
bendews 22 hours ago [-]
I think you have gone in to this with the exact mindset that I have had with the current Arc alternatives. My absolute *perfect* browser would be Safari with proper sidebar tabs and same-window profiles, and Air Control. Basically nothing else is needed.
This feels so close to that, well done!
ZigaoWang 19 hours ago [-]
That's pretty much exactly what I was going for! Air Traffic Control style routing just landed for the next beta! Its coming out to stabe soon. You can send a site to a space, and the space can have its own profile, with cookies seperate if u want that.
jawr 18 hours ago [-]
Any thoughts on having iCloud passwords be the default? I got it working by installing the extension and disabling all the password settings, but it’s clunky.
Otherwise really digging it!
ZigaoWang 18 hours ago [-]
Thanks! Glad you got it working. yeah right now it' clunky because you have to turn off Zigzag's own passwords by hand. Im going to make this into a proper section in Settings. So you can go to Settings -> Passwords, and you'll be able to pick iCloud Passwords, and Zigzag sets up Apple's extension and steps out of the way. Should be in the next beta.
jawr 8 hours ago [-]
The way searchbrowser does it is very nice! But zigzag’s spaces is way more intuitive
RalfBr 22 hours ago [-]
I switched from Zen to ZigZag. Not necessarily a faster browser in terms of speed, but the ram usage on my mac is 4x as low, which is a massive improvement! Thank you for building this.
ZigaoWang 18 hours ago [-]
Thank you! Using WebKit really do help with the RAM!
justauserid 20 hours ago [-]
When I see one of these posts I feel quite left out, if not FOMO. I would never know when that browser named Arc arrived on the scene, did something (quick search kinda tells me: agentic browsing for humans? maybe?) and apparently broke many hearts in the process (or just left without saying goodbye?), and so badly that people haven't been able to get over it and are still trying to get it all over again. Must be something. And here I am, still stuck on, like a broken record, which browser consumes less RAM (fluctuating betwreen Safari and Firefox all this while) – periodically ending in very sad realisations that in most cases it's the websites now, not so much the browsers anymore, unitl the search resumes for the n'th time.
euroderf 19 hours ago [-]
OT: Has anyone managed to make an improved Safari ? (By laying on the extensions and plugins and JS and CSS and whatever.)
NetOpWibby 23 hours ago [-]
Every Arc clone lacks the one feature I miss the most and that’s the Portrait mode.
Arc takes a screenshot of the current page in a minimal chrome wrapper and includes your desktop wallpaper.
I noticed you have a file size comparison against common browsers but the one I’ve been using on the side is Search[1]; you browser is 18 MB, Search clocks in at 10.2 MB.
[1]: https://searchbrowser.app
ZigaoWang 19 hours ago [-]
Portrait mode is a good one, im going to add that to the list. On size, I'm so so sorry. The 18 MB on the site was so out of date, it's about 35 MB now as the app grew. Still small next to the Chromium ones, but fair point on Search. I used Search for a while, but I just feel it is not that polished yet. Do try out Zigzag, thanks!
cush 22 hours ago [-]
This is the longest HN post I’ve ever seen
fouc 21 hours ago [-]
Love it, an Arc clone in webkit? SOLD!
build_with_ragh 23 hours ago [-]
Great initiative. Cant wait to try.
jcode1 22 hours ago [-]
whats difference between this and duckduck go ? it also uses swift and webkit
jcode1 21 hours ago [-]
also i just opened youtube and ram usage and it started another process that is consuming 500+ MBs in ram usage with just one tab is that normal ?
ZigaoWang 19 hours ago [-]
That's normal for any WebKit browser, Safari too. Each site runs in its own web process, and youtube indeed is heavy. That process is Youtube itself, not the browser. Zigzag also puts background tabs to sleep after a while, which frees that memory. I havent tried DuckduckGo, but according to my research, its more of a privacy-focused browser, rather than an Arc-replacement browser. Zigzag leans more towards UI/UX improvements, tho its still a browser that does privacy well!
itmd 22 hours ago [-]
I switched to Vivaldi and with some custom CSS it works very well
JulieZhao00 23 hours ago [-]
You're doing great job!
myzek 22 hours ago [-]
I don't want to be that guy, but I believe if you are looking for an Arc replacement it's much better to try out Zen (which is a Firefox underneath) than a new browser where Claude is in top contributors. Not hating, I just don't trust vibe coding and for a browser it's pretty important for it to be secure
ZigaoWang 19 hours ago [-]
Fair worry. On security, its uses WebKit shipped from macOS, so its engine gets software updates from Apple, and the pages run in a sandboxed process. The parts that read untrusted files, such as pdfs and images, run in separate sandboxed helpers. Stuff like ad blocking, reader mode and dark mode are built in, so you don't need extra extensions for them. A security researcher went through it twice and the fixes are public in the advisories. Yes, I use AI tools heavily. I review and test what goes in, but I get that people want to judge the code for themselves, and that's why it's all open source. Zen is great! But it's a Firefox under the hood, and I really want a lightweight and calm browser, so thats why I built Zigzag!
fwip 11 hours ago [-]
> But it is not another piece of AI slop app. I decide what it does and how it should feel, and every change goes through my own daily browsing before it ships.
I don't mean to be mean, and I'm not saying you're wrong - but this is what every vibe-coder says. Likely because Claude is constantly saying stuff like this.
ZigaoWang 9 hours ago [-]
Totally fair. Its open source with a few regular contributors sending issues and PRs constantly. Im hoping a community forms around it rather than it being just me and Claude. Either way, no pressure to switch now. Arc keeps working until Dec 22, and if there are anything that doesnt feel right, comment that and I’ll fix it!
I’ve been using it for about a year. It is buggy. And because it is Firefox-based is incapable of playback of certain media files. It’s okay. Just okay.
pindab0ter 17 hours ago [-]
I've also used it for about a year now, but have not run into any bugs. It is actively developed and gets new features in a steady pace, such as domain routing.
asdfsa32 22 hours ago [-]
Why is this down voted? Zen looks interesting on the surface, specially as Firefox is the last frontier of "Open Web" with Chrome and Safari being neutered by their respective corporate overlords and their closed gardens interests.
ifh-hn 22 hours ago [-]
Zen has some controversy a year or so ago related to security and privacy. Can remember the outcome but a lot of people here weren't happy with the dev response to it.
syncbehind 15 hours ago [-]
Why bother with a low effort comment like this, all it does it stokes unfounded fears? You've done nothing to share the actual controversy (if it can be called that).
Are you calling the comment I was replying to 'low effort' or my comment?
If it's the parent I don't understand what fears it's stoking.
If it's mine, I still don't understand what fears it's stoking. And who are you asking regarding bothering with my 'low effort' comment? Yourself? In which case why are you bothering? Or me? In which case are you asking for a source?
Y444 21 hours ago [-]
I assume it is downvoted, because the author explicitly mentioned Zen and described why it didn't suit them?
F3nd0 22 hours ago [-]
Eh, Firefox can also feel pretty neutered at times. In some aspects, Safari has even done better on the ‘Open Web’ front recently; I guess having several competing corporate overlords is better than having just one.
That said, I fully agree on the importance of Firefox. Avoiding Webkit/Blink monoculture is crucial.
someguyiguess 20 hours ago [-]
Yes. Firefox is the least reliable browser still. It has the most crashes, seems slower, and chokes on certain content. It’s better than being spied on but not by much.
I know I’ll get downvoted for disagreeing with the Firefox glazing hive mind but I’ve been developing for web browsers for almost 20 years. I’m not just hating on Firefox. It’s okay. Not terrible. Not great.
F3nd0 10 hours ago [-]
I don’t experience any such problems with Firefox. It works, it’s pretty fast and I don’t remember it crahsing on me in years.
Last time I used Chromium it rendered my entire desktop unusable after a reboot. I had to spend a while tracking the issue, only to find out it somehow messed up the font cache, which made a lot of other programs crash.
Safari, I have no personal experience with. Technically, I think all of the major browsers are comparable. It’s the care for privacy, freedom, and the open web which make Firefox the obvious choice, in spite of Mozilla’s recent direction.
I used firefox for a while but switched back because some sites didn't or rather some plugins caused issues with sites. The only thing I miss from firefox is how it managed containers and pinning websites to containers. Do recommend looking at that feature.
https://www.firefox.com/en-US/features/vertical-tabs/
Enroll in the beta, or wait a couple of weeks for the release.
Chrome (and Chromium-based) browsers are basically DOA now, and no reason to daily driver them if they can't implement a simple feature like this.
Like, I'm surprised anyone takes Chrome seriously at all after Google was told to not misuse their monopoly position as the world's largest ad company and remove the ability for the world's most popular ad blocker and security extension to work, and then did it anyways.
... and then promptly bullied all Chromium-based browsers to merge the Manifest V2 removal patches.
Talking about Manifest v3 is hypocticial when Firefox basically did the same thing to sidebar extensions. Tree Style Tabs had to fight for its extension APIs when they switched to Web Extensions (or it might have been Quantum?). Not to mention that they made userChrome disabled by default so TST/Sideberry users like me have to do a bunch of shenanigans in about:config that they might randomly feel like removing one day.
As a hardcore Arc user, my take away is I'm not trusting anything that has significant human effort and funding behind it. I don't have the time - nor interest - to spare to move browsers constantly so I can only choose to invest in something with structure behind it.
Something worth mentioning is that till this far, I samehow think Zigzag is suprisingly the best of all of them in terms of stability, coherence of the design, and sheer performance. It is really snappy, it doesn't have the overkill designs of the Arc (like the beautiful 3D opening of a folder for example) but it is more coherent than almost all the other versions I'm seening. But I hope I can find one even closer to Arc. Thanks again.
While great things can come from a solo developer, in this day and age it's not the mark of a well-engineered product it once was, in my eyes at least. I'm really hoping that a community springs up around one strong contender and it matures into something that can be trusted over many years to come.
Really I cannot overstate how fast/responsive it is. So smooth, no jank (I have 16GB M4 Air, when using Arc I can definitely see a small jank when opening & closing sidebar or resizing sidebar, swapping across spaces...) which I don't see at all in Zigzag
Also, I like how I can use chrome extensions here. Even though it's not 100% compatible, I can use ones that I have in my chromium browrser: ublock origin, unhook, video-speed-controller etc...
Some of the things I missed in safari are here, which I love: The reader mode & automatic dark mode support (removes need for me to use an extension for these "features")
overall idk if this is made with 100% AI or made by someone who actually have lot of knowledge and experience with building browsers, eitherways, from end user perspective, I love how its like Arc, but faster & uses safari engine (so its lightweight in MacOS)
Hello! Going by the comments, you're getting the classic HN welcome :D
Awesome start wth Zigzag. I feel like browsers are ripe for innovation beyond Arc too. E.g.:
- What does it mean to manage tabs & bookmarks in an agentic age?
- What would a start page look like if an agent can fetch anything from anywhere?
- What do projects and history look like when you can let Claude rip on visualizations and exploration to track tasks over time, not just by window or grouping?
Just some food for thought! :)
I remember an experimental browser that was released a bunch of years ago, I think it was by a university professor and their students. Its primary feature was a visual layout that showed history as sort of a storyboard of which pages led to each successive page. It was a neat concept. I was only aware of a single release and I don't remember the name, but I'd peg its ship date as around the age of Digg though I more likely saw it on Slashdot.
1. Anyone remember that? 2. Maybe we'll see something useful like that again. I hope so.
I am saying this because I hate having to write those conditions everywhere in my extension code to support different browsers, it’s error prone, and time taking. Now we have AI to do it and test it but earlier it was all me.
Someone mentioned the heavy usage of Claude, but for me the concern is another one. It's about the sustainability of the project and if this is just going to be discontinued like what happened to Arc.
As a user that needs to change his browser, I would understand what's going to be the future direction of this and if it can be economically viable for you to continue to work on the project. And just because it's open it doesn't mean that someone is going to take over
It feels like I’m one compromised plug-in update away from getting rolled…
This feels so close to that, well done!
Otherwise really digging it!
Arc takes a screenshot of the current page in a minimal chrome wrapper and includes your desktop wallpaper.
I noticed you have a file size comparison against common browsers but the one I’ve been using on the side is Search[1]; you browser is 18 MB, Search clocks in at 10.2 MB.
I don't mean to be mean, and I'm not saying you're wrong - but this is what every vibe-coder says. Likely because Claude is constantly saying stuff like this.
https://github.com/zen-browser/desktop/issues/5947 is this what you're referring to?
If it's the parent I don't understand what fears it's stoking.
If it's mine, I still don't understand what fears it's stoking. And who are you asking regarding bothering with my 'low effort' comment? Yourself? In which case why are you bothering? Or me? In which case are you asking for a source?
That said, I fully agree on the importance of Firefox. Avoiding Webkit/Blink monoculture is crucial.
Last time I used Chromium it rendered my entire desktop unusable after a reboot. I had to spend a while tracking the issue, only to find out it somehow messed up the font cache, which made a lot of other programs crash.
Safari, I have no personal experience with. Technically, I think all of the major browsers are comparable. It’s the care for privacy, freedom, and the open web which make Firefox the obvious choice, in spite of Mozilla’s recent direction.